Read the previous post first if you have no idea what I'm talking about.
I would have left this a few more days but I could do with actually getting on with the edit. Also my voting widget went weird and stopped working so I'm counting up the results from the various comments people left for me on here and on forums and Facebook etc.
And the night shot won!
By one vote...
Night - 9
Day - 8
This at least validates my indecisiveness as it seems to have divided everyone else too!
From reading the comments and feedback from everyone I've come to the following conclusion - the night shot is better in theory, it's just that technically the day scene looks better. This is mostly because we were on the beach at 10pm after a busy weekend of filming so we were trying to get it finished as quickly as possible. Plus we were in real danger of being eaten by weird jumping beach bugs.
This outtake just about sums it up -
I think with a little more time and preparation it would have come out better, although we were always going to be filming late at night so there was no way around that. And I'm not sure what we could've done about the beach bugs (shoot the antennae maybe?).
Despite this I am still going to go ahead with the night shoot as decided by the voters! This is partly because I want to see the whole thing in context with the other scenes before making a final FINAL decision. So I may still be editing two versions and could well be asking for your help again in the next few days.
Thanks to everyone who voted and left me comments about the shots! It definitely helped me make a decision and I really appreciate the feedback.
Please sign up to the mailing list at www.jennyringo.com and/or the Facebook page for regular progress reports!